2009年3月5日星期四

网络投票这玩意……

  新浪和搜狐两家报纸很天真很无邪地转述欧洲时报(中文报纸)再《费加罗》网站上的调查,声场《八成法国网民称应将兽首归还中国》具体是这么写的。
  不过,该报网络版做出的一项调查中,51680名法国网民参与,并有183人发表了评论。调查结果显示,81.48%的网民回答“是”,认为贝尔热应该将铜器还给中国;另有18.52%的网民回答“不”。
  让我深切的怀疑法国人的脑袋是不是让门夹过了,这么这么快就开始支持共产主义了。

  不过这两天练习argument有点多,忍不住想argue一下。写个提纲好了。
  In this argument, the arguer concludes that more than 80 percent French netizens support returning the regius tap to China. To support his/her conclusion, the arguer cites the survey on the website of Le Figaro which is a French newspaper. In my opinion, the arguer commit a critical fallacy.
  The arguer fails to convince us that the netizens who participate the survey are all French. As we know, Chinese can also participate the survey.
  Actually, we can find many posts on Chinese BBS, to call on Chinese to answer Oui, which means yes, on the survey. Moreover, according to the posts,at the beginning the Non which mean no, is twice as much as Oui. It is more likely that many Chinese netizen affect the result of the survey.

  google一下:费加罗报关于圆明园国宝是否应归还中国的投票

没有评论:

发表评论